QuoteGeekFor the lines that stay with you.

People · 1859

He could not have been tried by a jury of his peers, because his peers did not exist.

— Henry David Thoreau • A Plea for Captain John Brown

Painterly three empty wooden chairs arranged on a grey floor against a bare wall.
Original artwork
Behind the line May contain spoilers.

Our reading

An editorial interpretation.

The passage turns the idea of a jury of peers into a claim that this person had no equals. The argument makes ordinary comparison impossible. Read as praise within a defence, it elevates the person judged above the measure that a trial would ordinarily require.

Context reviewed

Share this quote