Two teenage friends talk beside school lockers.

Original artwork, not a still

Chris "Oz" Ostreicher and Jim Levenstein, American Pie

Like warm apple pie. / McDonald’s or homemade?

— American Pie · 1999

Watch the scene May contain spoilers.
On screen

American Pie

YouTube · Universal Pictures

Official scene clip · Scene checked

Watch on YouTube

Behind the line

What it means

Our interpretation.

A sly analogy gets taken far too literally by someone with no experience. Fans quote the question whenever advice turns out to be useless.

Context reviewed

In context

Spoilers for American PieShow the scene

While the boys discuss what third base feels like, Oz offers warm apple pie as the comparison and Jim asks the question that sets up the later pie scene: McDonald's or homemade? The earnest follow-up is the joke, because Jim treats a dubious metaphor as a shopping decision. The film was edited from an NC-17 rating to an R.

Sources (3)

Context reviewed

Share this quote