A white-haired swordsman with two blades on his back stands at a foggy forest crossroads by a lantern-lit wayside shrine at dusk.

Original artwork, not a still

The Last Wish • 1993

Geralt of Rivia

If I'm to choose between one evil and another, I'd rather not choose at all.

Behind the line

What it means

Our interpretation.

It is Geralt's whole creed in one shrug: neutrality as a moral position, not an excuse. The story exists to show how hollow that creed turns out to be, since refusing to choose is still a choice, and fans quote it both sincerely and as the setup to that irony. Players of the games, where Wild Hunt's grim moral choices are the signature, adopt it as the series' unofficial motto.

Context reviewed

In context

Spoilers for The Last WishShow the scene

The line belongs to Sapkowski's short story "The Lesser Evil" in The Last Wish, and is heard in the Netflix series The Witcher, episode 1, "The End's Beginning". Geralt has gone to the tower where the mage Stregobor is hiding. Stregobor begs him to kill Renfri, a woman cursed under the Black Sun who hunts him, as "the lesser evil". Geralt refuses, says evil is evil whether lesser, greater or middling, and that he would rather not choose at all, then leaves. The choice follows him to Blaviken, where Renfri's bandits arrive and the argument ends in blood.

Sources (3)

Context reviewed

Share this quote