Tin cup of water on a low rusted tray

Original artwork, not a still

Lewis Gordon Pugh

Never, ever did I think that there would be a debate in this arid country about which was more important – gas or water. We can survive without gas. We cannot live without water.

— Karoo Anti-Fracking Speech to Shell in Cape Town, 25 March 2011

Behind the line

What it means

Our interpretation.

Pugh sets two needs side by side and makes the choice obvious. Gas can be done without, but water can't. In a dry country, he finds it almost unbelievable that the question even needs debating at all.

Context reviewed

Share this quote