Illustration of a man in a grey suit seen from behind in an office interview chair, gesturing mid-complaint, a baseball bat and glove propped against the partition.

Original artwork, not a still

Michael Scott

Fool me once, strike one. Fool me twice, strike three.

— The Office (U.S.)  ·  2005

Behind the line

What it means

Our interpretation.

Michael takes the proverb about being tricked, swaps in a baseball count, and ends up with a rule that makes no sense and is delivered with total confidence. It is the show's Michael in miniature: a man sure he is being wise while garbling the idiom. Fans quote it as the stock example of a mangled saying and use it as a joke about grudges.

Context reviewed

In context

Spoilers for The Office (U.S.)Show the scene

In "Traveling Salesmen" (The Office US, season 3, episode 13, first aired 11 January 2007), Michael sends the sales staff out in pairs on cold calls, and Andy spends the day poisoning him against Dwight. When a toll receipt suggests Dwight secretly went to corporate headquarters in New York, Michael takes it as a fresh betrayal, coming after Dwight's earlier attempt to take his job in "The Coup". In a talking-head interview about it, he mangles two proverbs into this threat. Dwight ends the episode by resigning rather than explain where he was.

Sources (3)

Context reviewed

Share this quote